Skip to content

Using book value to spot undervalued shares

Photo of James Carlisle By James Carlisle

min read

Shares are worth the present value of the future cash they generate. We can either look at this cash in terms of the dividends paid out, or the net cash the company produces.

In spite of a few shortcomings (one of which we’ll come to shortly), this theory does provide a framework for comparing different companies whatever they do with their cash. But if you give an analyst a theoretical framework, he or she will give you a 15-page spreadsheet.

After all, if a company is worth the present value of its future cash flows, then why not put together a giant sum, calculating all those cash flows, discounting them back to their present value and totting them all up? Called “discounted cash flow” calculations, they’re all the rage these days but, curiously, not so much before the advent of the computer.

In practice, such valuations aren't worth the space they take up on your hard drive.

First, you can get so wrapped up in the calculations it’s easy to forget about the numbers you put in.  Second, as you combine estimates, the results become so rough to be of little use.

Finally, there’s a temptation to award the final result too much credibility because of all the effort embedded in your elegant spreadsheet.

The better bet is to stick to a few simple valuation tools – such as price-to-book, dividend yield and the Price Earnings (PE) multiple – and then allow a fat margin of safety. But it’s essential to see these tools purely in the context of helping you reach an estimate of the present value of a company’s future cash flows.

The simplest tool of all is the price-to-book ratio, which is a company’s market capitalisation divided by its net asset value (or ‘book value’). Book value represents what the company has paid for all its stuff and what it would receive were it to sell it all and return the proceeds to shareholders.

Accounting confusion

The beauty of book value lies in its simplicity, although there are a couple of problems with it.

First, book value doesn’t represent the value of a company’s assets but what it paid for them, less an arbitrary charge for wear and tear, and plus or minus the odd bit of accounting confusion. So you have to be careful about the assets to include in your book value and the values ascribed to them.

Plant and machinery dedicated to a declining industry might have a much lower value than what is actually stated on the balance sheet. Other assets, like cash, have a more definite value. In between, there are things like inventory and debtors, whose value will depend on how confident you are that they can be converted successfully into cash.

Some assets, such as property, might be understated, and some valuable intangible assets, like brands, goodwill and intellectual property, might not even show up at all. The Coca-Cola Company had a book value of $US25 billion in April, but according to Interbrand, its main brand is worth $US78 billion. Even that may be on the low side if the company’s US$200 billion market capitalisation is anything to go by.

So it’s all a bit circular. All roads eventually lead back to the fundamental truism that a piece of capital is worth what it can earn.

Not all capital is created equal

Which gets us to our second problem – that companies don’t all make the same returns. Some companies consistently make returns far above average, either because of competitive advantages or good management, or both. Economic theory says these factors should be ironed out over time, but in practice they can hang around for ages.

All things being equal, then, a good business making high returns on capital will justify a higher price-to-book ratio than a poor business making low returns.

So the advantage of the price-to-book ratio is that it is quick and easy; the disadvantage is that it often won’t tell you much about a company’s value. That said, it can provide useful pointers.

About the author

James Carlisle is Research Director of Intelligent Investor. To unlock Intelligent Investor stock research and buy recommendations, take out a 15-day free membership here.

Follow: @value_investing

From ASX

ASX online courses cover shares, interest-rate securities, warrants and instalments, exchange-traded funds, options and futures. The shares course has 11 modules, each taking 10 to 15 minutes to complete. Topics covered include: What is a share?; How to invest; Risk and benefits of shares; What to consider in an investment; and How to buy and sell shares. Simple summaries and quizzes in each module make learning fast, easy and enjoyable.

The views, opinions or recommendations of the author in this article are solely those of the author and do not in any way reflect the views, opinions, recommendations, of ASX Limited ABN 98 008 624 691 and its related bodies corporate ("ASX"). ASX makes no representation or warranty with respect to the accuracy, completeness or currency of the content. The content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Independent advice should be obtained from an Australian financial services licensee before making investment decisions. To the extent permitted by law, ASX excludes all liability for any loss or damage arising in any way including by way of negligence.

© Copyright 2015 ASX Limited ABN 98 008 624 691. All rights reserved 2015.
Previous Next